Re: Gordon Cheers new book

John Taylor [The Banshee] (rphjt@minyos.xx.rmit.OZ.AU)
Thu, 11 Feb 93 16:11:55 +0000

>I just got my copy of Gordon Cheer's new book "A Guide to Carnivorous
>Plants of the World". It is definitely worth buying, but is more of a
>picture book than a comprehensive reference. In general style it
>reminds me of Lecoufle's book with gorgeous color plates for each
>species, and a set format for describing each plant. The text is much
>better than Lecoufle, with several interesting sections such as: a
>travel guide to world CP sites (with pictures), a historical review of
>carnivorous plants, plus a short bit on tissue culture techniques. I
>was annoyed to find that Jan's CP World list was nearly copied verbatum
>(sans bibliographic references) while only giving attribution to the
>CPN article.

Except that Jan's list is far more comprehensive than Gordon's, and
doesn't have the typing errors found in the new book either! However,
it definitely is a good book and is well worth the expense of having to
buy it as a hardback..

>Quite interesting reading, but I am still hoping for someone to publish
>a book that covers more than the top 20-30 most popular species, and
>with more emphasis on culture and taxonomy.

This would be a great book - great as in *huge*! Allen Lowrie's series
looks like being at least 3 volumes (officially it was a 3 volume set,
but I can't see how he'll squeeze the rest of the species into the last
book) and that only covers Australian species. Now, granted it is a
smaller format than most books but to cover all world species would make
at least 4 large volumes? (I'm guessing...) Apart from the work
involved in putting such a book together, it would probably be
out-of-date in terms of species names (and new plants) before it could
be finished... Still, it would be nice to have such a book :-)

BFN

+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
| John Taylor [The Banshee] | Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology |
| rphjt@minyos.xx.rmit.oz.au | Department of Applied Physics |
| MOKING IS A HEALTH HAZARD. | Melbourne, Victoria, AUSTRALIA |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+